Seeing how
Christianity is counter-cultural to democracy
11/11/2025
Luke
17:7-10 Jesus
said to the Apostles: "Who among you would say to your servant who has
just come in from plowing or tending sheep in the field, 'Come here immediately
and take your place at table'? Would he not rather say to him, 'Prepare
something for me to eat. Put on your apron and wait on me while I eat and
drink. You may eat and drink when I am finished'? Is he grateful to that
servant because he did what was commanded? So should it be with you. When you
have done all you have been commanded, say, 'We are unprofitable servants; we
have done what we were obliged to do.'"
The
Christian faith is deeply counter-cultural, and this contrast with contemporary
culture has been highlighted by the recent No Kings Marches around the country.
Now my purpose is not to score any political points but rather to make a
theological one. Ever since the American Revolution of 1776, when we threw off
the yoke of tyrannous King George III, Americans have championed democracy, or
rule by the people.
We
have fought wars in defense of democracy; we have supported economic policies
in favor of democracy; and have helped overthrow despotic governments to
promote democracy. And so the No Kings March follows in the same vein,
regardless of whether you personally feel it is right or wrong-headed.
Democracy is the irresistible cultural current in which we American fish swim.
But
democracy is exactly the wrong lens through which to understand Christianity. A
better lens is hierarchy, which flies in the face of the opening lines of the
Declaration of Independence, “that all men are created equal.” I tried to
explain this underlying hierarchy in creation to a Bible study group who called
me from Florida with some questions about the angels.
I
said that God created the cosmos with natural superiors and inferiors. At the
top of the hierarchical ladder stands God, below him on the next rung are the
angels, below the angels are humans, and below man are animals, and below them
are plants, and finally at the bottom are the rocks and other inanimate matter.
Inanimate literally means “without souls.”
The
harmony, happiness, and holiness of the entire cosmos require every inferior to
obey and submit to its natural superior. And that hierarchical harmony is
precisely what the angels disrupted and tried to destroy when they rebelled
against God, and fought their Revolutionary War.
Revelation
12 describes this angelic rebellion when Satan, the first fallen angel, swept a
third of the stars – meaning 1/3 of the angels – from the sky. We might say
Satan led the very first No Kings March to overthrow the reign of God as their
king. Incidentally, you might enjoy reading C. S. Lewis’ book A Preface to
Paradise Lost, and the chapter simply called “Hierarchy” if you want a deep
dive into this topic of hierarchy versus democracy.
The
reason I am going to all the trouble to explain the difference between
democracy and hierarchy is not only because it makes Christianity hard to
understand, but it makes the Bible opaque as well. For example, in today’s
gospel Jesus speaks about masters and servants.
And
those categories immediately sound like nails on a chalkboard to the ears of
people who walk in a No Kings March, that is, to modern American saturated in
democracy. Indeed, Jesus’ take-home message will sound utterly nonsensical,
even offensive, to democratic Americans: “When you have done all you have been
commanded say, ‘We are unprofitable servants; we have done what we were obliged
to do’.”
In
other words, Jesus calls Christians to be like salmon and swim upstream against
the modern democratic cultural current. As C. S. Lewis puts it: “The goodness,
happiness, and dignity of every being consists in obeying its natural superior
and ruling its natural inferior” (92). The Bible makes more sense the more we
think hierarchically and the less we think democratically.
We
find the same hierarchical principle operative in the Church and in the
liturgy. The priesthood is ordered in a hierarchy of authority: deacons at the
bottom, then priests, bishops, cardinals, and the pope at the top. The harmony
of the Church depends on the inferior obeying the superior. Can you imagine the
chaos that would be unleashed if the deacons organized a No Kings March in Rome
protesting the prerogatives of the pope?
The
movements of the liturgy, at Mass, all the kneeling, sitting, standing reflect
the hierarchy of the human priest and the divine Priest, Jesus. That is why we
genuflect on one knee when we come into church and enter our pew. That is why
deacons bow before the priest and ask his blessing before reading the gospel.
That is why altar servers are called “servers.” And they should leave Mass
repeating what Jesus said in the gospel, “We have done what we were obliged to
do.”
My
friends, the moment we step out of our cars and into a Catholic church, we step
into a very undemocratic world. The flood waters of modern democracy that have
washed over the entire world ever since the American Revolution may splash
against the doors of the Church, but do not dare to enter. And if you have been
imbibing that cultural Kool-Aid, then when you walk into Mass, you will feel
very much like a fish out of water.
Praised be Jesus Christ!






